The Serpent's Counsel

Germanus: Nos hactenus credebamus causam initiumque ruinae seu praevaricationis diabolicae, qua de angelica statione deiectus est, invidiam specialiter exstitisse, quando Adam et Evam livida calliditate decepit. Serenus: Non esse istud initium praevaricationis illius seu deiectionis, Geneseos lectio manifestat, quae, ante illorum deceptionem, serpentini nominis eum nota credidit inurendum, ita dicens: Serpens autem erat sapientior, sive, ut Hebraici exprimunt libri, callidior cunctis bestiis terrae quas fecit Dominus Deus. Intelligitis ergo quod ante illam circumventionem primi hominis, de angelica discesserat sanctitate; ita ut non solum nominis huius insigniri mereretur infamia, sed etiam in nequitiae tergiversatione caeteris praeferretur bestiis terrae. Non enim tali vocabulo Scriptura bonum angelum designasset, nec de his qui in illa beatitudine perseverant diceret, Serpens autem erat sapientior omnibus bestiis terrae. Nam hoc cognomen non solum Gabrieli, sive Michaeli, nullo modo posset aptari, sed ne bono quidem cuiquam homini conveniret. Apertissime itaque et serpentis vocabulum, et comparatio bestiarum, non sonat angeli dignitatem, sed praevaricatoris infamiam. Denique livoris ac seductionis materia, qua ut hominem deciperet instigatus est, de anterioris ruinae exstitit causa, quod scilicet de limo terrae nuperrime figuratum ad illam eum gloriam cerneret evocandum, unde, cum esset unus de principibus, se meminerat corruisse. Et idcirco priorem eius lapsum, quo superbiendo corruerat, quo etiam serpens meruerat nuncupari, secunda ruina per invidiam subsecuta est: quae inveniens eum adhuc aliquid in sese rectum habentem, ita ut etiam cuiusdam colloquii atque consilii cum homine posset habere consortium, sententia Domini utiliter in ima deiectus est; ut non iam, sicut ante, sublime aliquid intuens excelsus incederet, sed ut solo cohaerens reperet, et humiliatus super ventrem terrenis vitiorum escis et operibus pasceretur, occultum deinceps publicans inimicum, ac ponens inter ipsum et hominem utiles inimicitias salutaremque discordiam; ut dum cavetur tamquam hostis noxius, amicitiis fraudulentis ulterius homini nocere non posset. In quo tamen et illud nos praecipue debet instruere, ut a malis consiliis declinemus; quod licet deceptionis auctor congrua poena et condemnatione plectatur, ne ille quidem qui seducitur, supplicio careat, licet aliquantulo leviore quam ille qui auctor deceptionis exstiterit. Quod hic expressum plenissime cernimus: Adam namque qui seductus est, immo, ut Apostoli verbis eloquar, qui seductus non est, sed seductae acquiescens, in exitialem videtur accessisse consensum, sudore vultus ac labore tantummodo condemnatur, qui tamen illi, non per suam, sed per terrae maledictionem sterilitatemque decernitur. Mulier vero, quae huius rei persuasor exstitit, multiplicationem gemituum ac dolorum atque tristitiae promeretur, perpetuo pariter iugo subiectionis addicta. Serpens autem, qui primus incentor huius offensae est, perenni maledictione mulctatur. Quamobrem summa sollicitudine et circumspectione cavendum est a consiliis pravis, quia sicut auctorem puniunt, ita deceptum nec peccato faciunt carere, nec poena. Sanctus Ioannes Cassianus, Collationes, Collatio Octava, De Principatibus Seu Potestatibus, Caput IX-XI Source: Migne PL 49.736b-739a

Germanus: Until now we believed that the reason and beginning of the ruin and error of the devil, by which he was cast down from the angelic state, was most particularly envy, when in his malicious cleverness he deceived Adam and Eve. Serenus: That this was not the beginning of his fall and ruin, the passage in Genesis shows, as before their deception it deems him to be already branded with the name of serpent, so saying: 'But the serpent was wiser,' or as the Hebrew books express it, 'more clever than all the beasts of the earth, which the Lord God had made.' 1 You understand, then, that before he deceived the first man, he had fallen away from angelic sanctity, so that he not only deserved to be stamped with the infamy of that name, but indeed surpassed all other beasts of the earth in the subterfuges of wickedness. For Scripture would not have designated a good angel in such a way, nor would it say of those who remained in that state of bliss: 'But the serpent was wiser than all the beasts of the earth.' For it is not only that this title could not possibly be applied to Gabriel or Michael, but it would not even befit any good man. And so the title of serpent and the comparison to beasts most clearly declares the wickedness of an apostate not the dignity of an angel. Finally the occasion of envy and seduction which drove him to deceive man, arose from the cause of his previous ruin, that is, he saw that one who had just recently been shaped from the mud of the earth was to be called to that glory from which he remembered that he himself, when he was one of the princes, had fallen. And so that first ruin of his, in which he fell by pride, and which earned for him the name of serpent, was followed by a second because of envy, which finding him still having something upright, so that he could yet have some conversation and counsel with man, the Lord's sentence very rightly cast him down into the depths, that he might no longer, as before, walk erect and look on high, but cleaving to the ground creep along, and being brought low on his belly, feed on earthly food and works of vices, and thereafter announce his secret hostility and set between himself and man a useful enmity and a salutary discord, so that while man is wary of him as a dangerous enemy, he can no longer harm him with fraudulent friendship. In which matter, however, we should especially learn, so that we may shun evil counsels, that though the author of the deception was struck with a fitting punishment and condemnation, nor did the one who was seduced lack a penalty, although it was somewhat lighter than his who was the author of the deception. And this we see was very plainly expressed. For Adam, who was deceived, or rather, to speak in the Apostle's words, 'was not deceived' 2 but, consenting to her who was deceived seems to have given a fatal agreement, is only condemned to labour and the sweat of his face, which, however, is given to him not through a curse on himself, but by a curse upon the earth and its barrenness. But the woman, who persuaded him, receives a multiplication of groans and pains and sorrow, together with the yoke of perpetual subjection. But the serpent, who was the first to incite them to this offense, is punished by an endless curse. For which reason we should beware, with the utmost care and circumspection, evil counsels, for as they punish their authors, so they do not spare the deceived fault, nor punishment. Saint John Cassian, Conferences, from Conference 8, On Principalites And Powers, Chaps 9-11 1 Gen 3.1 2 1 Tim 2.14