Wisdom And Sobriety

Non plus sapere quam oportet sapere, sed sapere ad sobrietatem. Videtur adhuc superbientes ramos oleastri, et insultantes ramis qui de bona oliva defracti sunt, etiam hunc aptare sermon, et dicere eis, non debere plus sapere quam oportet sapere: quod simile est illi sermoni quem dixit: Noli superbe sapere; hoc est enim plus sapere quam oportet. Sciendum tamen est, quod et caeteri eruditi viri utuuntur hoc definitione, ut naturam vel causam peccati in eo ponant, si aut addatur aliquid virtutibus, aut minuatur. Verbi gratia, justitia virtus est: et si quis minus aliquid facit quam justitia patitur, sine dubio injustus est. Si quis vero sub specie justitiae erga vindictas nimius fiat, et saevius agitet ultiones, in crudelitatem, ex justitia devolutus est. Unde et Salomon dicit: Noli fieri justus multum. Similiter et libertas, si intra temperantiam suam sit, virtus est, si minus habeat, timiditas, si amplius, temeritas nominantur. Pari modo et prudentia si sua mensura sit, virtus est, si minus habeat imprudentia, si plusquam oportet, malitia appellatur. Inde puto quod et serpens in paradiso prudentior dictus sit caeteris bestiis, hoc est excedens mensuram prudentiae, est partes malitiae prolapsus. Inde et filii hujus saeculi prudentiores dicuntur quam filii lucis; plus enim sapiunt quam oportet sapere. Et sic in singulis quibusque virtutibus potest aliquis plus sapere quam oportet sapere, ut sunt illi qui attendunt spiritibus seductoribus, et doctrinis daemoniorum, in hypocrisi falsa loquentes, cauteriatem habentes conscientiam suam, prohibentes nubere, et abstinentes se a cibos quos Deus creavit. Isti plus sapiunt de castitate quam oportet. Minus autem sapit quam oportet luxuriosus et incestus. Ego autem dico quod et haeretici plus sapiunt de Christo quam oportet sapere, qui negant eum Dei creatoris esse Filium, sed alterius nescio cujus melioris Dei. Sed et illi plus de Christo sapiunt quam oportet sapere, qui negant eum in carne venisse, et natuam esse ex Virgine, sed coeleste ei corpus assignant. In his ergo omnibus Paulus nos vult non plus sapere quam oportet sapere, sed sapere ad sobrietatem. Origenes, Commentariorum In Epistolam Beati Pauli Ad Romanos, Liber IX, Interprete Rufino Aquileiense Source: Migne PG 14.1209c-1210c

Do not know more than it is fitting to know, but know soberly. 1 It seems that this is appropriately directed to the yet proud branches of the wild olive and the offended branches which have been broken off from the good olive, 2 and he says to them that they should not know more than it is fitting to know. But it must be understood that even other educated men use this definition, so that they place the nature or cause of error in it, if something is added to the virtues or taken away. 3 For the sake of an example, justice is a virtue, but if someone does less than justice requires he is without doubt unjust, but then if someone beneath the form of justice is vindictive and wildly seeks revenge, even to cruelty, he has utterly fallen away from justice. Whence Solomon says, 'Do not be too just.' 4 Similarly with liberty, if it has temperance, it is a virtue, but if there is a lack there is timidity, and if there is excess, it is named temerity. In like manner if wisdom has its measure it is a virtue, but if there is lack there is imprudence, and if there is too much than is fitting, it is named wickedness. Hence I think that the serpent in paradise was said to have been more wise than the other animals, that is, it exceeded the measure of wisdom, and fell into evil. And the sons of this age are said to be wiser than the sons of light, for they know more than they should know. 5 So it is that in each virtue it is possible than someone may know more than is fitting, so that they are 'those who attend to seductive sprits and the teachings of demons, speaking falsely in hypocrisy, and wounding their own conscience, forbidding marriage and abstaining from foods that God has created.' 6 These know more than is fitting for purity. But they who know less than is fitting are those who are indulge in luxury and uncleanliness. And I say that even heretics know more about Christ than is fitting, those who deny that He is the Son of God the Creator, but have some other better God for him, I know not who. And they know more of Christ than they should who deny He has come in the flesh and was born of a virgin and assign Him a heavenly body. Therefore Paul does not want us to know more than is fitting in all these things, but to know soberly. Origen, from the Commentary on the Letter of Saint Paul to the Romans, Book 9, Translated by Rufinus of Aquileia. 1 Rom 12.3 2 Rom 11.17-25 3 The Golden Mean, cf Aristoltle Nic Eth Book II, 1106b- 4 Eccl 7.17 5 Gen 3.1, Lk 16.8 6 1 Tim 4.1-3